• Home
  • RSS Feeds
  • Blog Archives
Subscribe to Disputing
Book an ADR Service
Call Karl Bayer
Karl Bayer's Disputing Blog - Mediator, Arbitrator, Court Master & Technical Advisor
About Karl  |  Book an ADR Service  |  Contact Karl   (214) 891-4505

Menu 
  • home
  • Mediation
  • Arbitration
  • Court Neutrals
  • Online Dispute Resolution
  • Technology
    • Intellectual Property
    • Privacy and Cybersecurity
    • E-discovery
  • Court Decisions
    • Texas Supreme Court
    • Fifth Circuit
    • Third Court of Appeals
    • U.S. Supreme Court
  • More
    • Legislation
      • Texas
      • United States
    • Healthcare
    • Guest Posts
      • John DeGroote
      • John C. Fleming
      • Rick Freeman
      • Professor Peter Friedman
      • Honorable W. Royal Furgeson, Jr.
      • James M. Gaitis
      • Laura A. Kaster
      • Professor John Lande
      • Philip J. Loree, Jr.
      • Michael McIlwrath
      • F. Peter Phillips
      • Professor Alan Scott Rau
      • Professor Thomas J. Stipanowich
      • Professor S.I. Strong
      • Richard Webb
      • Glen M. Wilkerson
    • International arbitration
    • Regulation
    • Sports and Entertainment


Thursday, November 2, 2005

0
by Rob Hargrove

Thursday, Nov 03, 2005


Tweet

The Third Court of Appeals issued three opinions this morning. The first, which came from a case against the City of San Angelo Fire Department, explains an affirmative defense to the Texas Tort Claims Act’s waiver of sovereign immunity for claims involving the use of a motor vehicle. While sovereign immunity is usually waived in Texas in cases where a governmental employee negligently operates a motor vehicle, there is no waiver in cases where the claim arises out of the action of an employee responding to an emergency call in compliance with applicable laws and ordinances.

The plaintiff in the underlying case had sued the San Angelo Fire Department after she got into a wreck with a fire engine responding to a report of a burning daycare center. According to the Court of Appeals, San Angelo established that its fire fighter had obeyed applicable regulations in responding to the call, so the City’s sovereign immunity from the claim was not waived by the Tort Claims Act, and the trial court had no subject-matter jurisdiction over the City.

Finally, the Court found that the fire fighter in question was entitled to official immunity, as he was performing a discretionary act at the time of the accident, and he was acting in good faith as the first unit responding to what he believed was a burning daycare facility with children trapped inside.

Cause No. 03-04-00179-CV, City of San Angelo and Kelly Hood v. Hudson

The Third Court of Appeals also issued memorandum opinions in a case for termination of parental rights and a restricted appeal of a default divorce.

Related Posts

  • Sovereign Immunity ProcedureSovereign Immunity Procedure
  • The Doctrine of Ecclesiastical AbstentionThe Doctrine of Ecclesiastical Abstention
  • The State Waives Sovereign Immunity from Counterclaims when it SuesThe State Waives Sovereign Immunity from Counterclaims when it Sues
  • Wednesday, December 14, 2005Wednesday, December 14, 2005
  • Dallas COA Holds TAA Preempts Collateral Fraud ClaimsDallas COA Holds TAA Preempts Collateral Fraud Claims
  • Dallas COA Dismisses Arbitration Award for Lack of JurisdictionDallas COA Dismisses Arbitration Award for Lack of Jurisdiction

Like this article? Share it!


  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
    LinkedIn

  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window)
    X

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
    Facebook

  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
    Pinterest

  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
    Email
About

Legal Research

Legal Research

Connect with Disputing

Visit Us On LinkedinCheck Our Feed

About Disputing

Disputing is published by Karl Bayer, a dispute resolution expert based in Austin, Texas. Articles published on Disputing aim to provide original insight and commentary around issues related to arbitration, mediation and the alternative dispute resolution industry.

To learn more about Karl and his team, or to schedule a mediation or arbitration with Karl’s live scheduling calendar, visit www.karlbayer.com.

About Disputing

Disputing is published by Karl Bayer, a dispute resolution expert based in Austin, Texas. Articles published on Disputing aim to provide original insight and commentary around issues related to arbitration, mediation and the alternative dispute resolution industry.

To learn more about Karl and his team, or to schedule a mediation or arbitration with Karl’s live scheduling calendar, visit www.karlbayer.com.

Recent Posts

We're Back!!!!
Feb 24, 2025
JAMS Welcomes Karl Bayer to its Panel of Neutrals
JAMS Welcomes Karl Bayer to its Panel of Neutrals
May 28, 2024
Class Action Waivers in Arbitration Agreements: The Twenty-First Century Arbitration Battleground and Implications for the EU Countries
Nov 27, 2023

Featured Posts

Tips on Taking Good Remote Depositions From a Veteran Court Reporter

Online Mediation May Allow Restorative Justice to Continue During COVID-19

Remote Arbitration Best Practices: Witness Examination

Search

Legal Research

Legal Research


© 2025, Karl Bayer. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy