Menu
Court Decisions about Arbitration
2009 Arbitration Case Law: U.S. Supreme Court
By Victoria VanBuren - December 8, 2009
Welcome to Disputing‘s 2009 Year-End Highlights. During this year, the U.S. Supreme Court decided several cases related to arbitration: On March 9, the Court decided Vaden v. Discover Bank. The issues were (1) whether a district court, if asked to compel arbitration, should “look through” the petition and grant the relief if the court would have federal-question jurisdiction of the controversy and (2) whether a district court should exercis
Fifth Circuit Affirms Confirmation of NASD Arbitration Award
By Victoria VanBuren - December 5, 2009
In The Householder Group v. Caughran, No. 09-40111 (5th. Cir. Nov. 11, 2009), the court summarizes the facts as follows: [A] panel of arbitrators with the National Association of Securities Dealers, Inc. (“NASD”) awarded Householder Group $39,500 in compensatory damages for breach of a promissory note, $50,000 in compensatory damages for breach of a Branch Office Agreement, and $70,000 in attorneys fees. Thereafter, Householder Group filed a moti
Texas Supreme Court Compels Nonsignatories to Arbitrate Wrongful Death Claims
By Victoria VanBuren - December 2, 2009
In re Golden Peanut Co., (Texas 2009) (No. 09-0122) deals with family members who brought a wrongful death action against Grant Drennan’s employer, Golden Peanut Company, LLC. (“Golden Peanut”). Golden Peanut did not subscribe to worker’s compensation insurance, but provided an Employee Injury Benefit Plan which called for binding arbitration of employment-related claims. Golden Peanut filed a motion to compel arbitration.
Tenth Circuit Decides Manifest Disregard of the Law Case and Imposes Sanctions Under 28 U.S.C. § 1927 for ‘Frivolous’ Attempt to Vacate Arbitration Award
By Victoria VanBuren - December 1, 2009
[Hat tip to our blog contributor Peter S. Vogel] The United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit held that an arbitrator did not act with manifest disregard of the law when he turned to extrinsic evidence to determine the parties’ intent. The court also granted sanctions to compensate the company for unnecessary legal fees incurred when the other party appealed the arbitral award. I. Background In DMA Int’l, Inc. v. Qwest Com
Disputing Guest Post | Hall Street Meets S. Maestri Place: What Standards of Review will the Fifth Circuit Apply to Arbitration Awards Under FAA Section 10(a)(4) after Citigroup?
By Victoria VanBuren - November 19, 2009
As the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit decides more “manifest disregard” of the law cases, we thought that you might be interested in reading our guest-post published at the Loree Reinsurance and Arbitration Law Forum earlier this year. Check it out! Hall Street Meets S. Maestri Place: What Standards of Review will the Fifth Circuit Apply to Arbitration Awards Under FAA Section 10(a)(4) after Citigroup? By Victori
Fifth Circuit Reaffirms that the FAA Provides the Exclusive Grounds for Vacatur of Arbitration Awards After Hall Street v. Mattel
By Victoria VanBuren - November 18, 2009
In United Forming, Inc. v. Faulknerusa, LP, No. 09-50073 (5th Cir. Oct. 27, 2009), FaulknerUSA, LP (Faulkner) is the general contractor at a construction project; United Forming, Inc. (United) is a sub-contractor; and Continental Casualty, Co. (Continental) is the surety of their agreement. After a dispute over United’s work, the parties submitted their claims to arbitration before an American Arbitration Association (AAA) panel. The panel
Texas Supreme Court Compels Arbitration of Employment Discrimination Claims
By Victoria VanBuren - November 10, 2009
The Supreme Court of Texas held that an agreement to arbitrate discrimination claims between an employee and a staffing agency hired by the employer survives the dissolution of the contract between the staffing agency and employer. In the present case, In re Polymerica, __S.W.3d __ (Tex. 2009) (No. 08-1064), Polymerica, L.L.C. d.b.a Global Enterprises, Inc. (“Global”), a manufacture of plastics, hired Angelica Soltero in 1998. In 2002, Global con
Florida Arbitration Law: Wife Verbally OK’s Husband to Sign Papers Is Agency to Sign Arbitration Clause
By Victoria VanBuren - November 5, 2009
In contrast to our discussion of Koricic v. Beverly Enters. in which the Nebraska Supreme Court held that a son lacked authority to sign an arbitration agreement on behalf of his mother, a recent trial court in Florida ruled in Christenson, v. The Abbey Rehabilitation and Nursing Center that a husband had apparent authority to sign a nursing home arbitration agreement. From Florida Arbitration Law.com: In Christenson, the validity of an arbitrati
Texas Supreme Court: Insurance Coverage Dispute Involving a $1.5 Million Arbitration Award
By Victoria VanBuren - November 5, 2009
Within the five opinions released by the Texas Supreme Court on October 30, Chrysler Insurance Co. v. Greenspoint Dodge of Houston, Inc., (Texas 2009) (No. 08?0780) caught our attention. The case deals with a dispute over insurance coverage to pay for a $1.5 million defamation arbitration award granted to Noe Martinez, a former employee of Greenspoint. The award was confirmed by a district court in Harris County back in 2002. See Martinez. v. Gre
Nebraska Supreme Court Refuses to Compel Arbitration in Nursing Home Case
By Victoria VanBuren - November 4, 2009
The present case comes as the U.S. Congress considers the Fairness in Nursing Home Arbitration Act of 2009. This Act would render pre-dispute arbitration clauses in nursing home contracts unenforceable (Senate version: S.512 and Status; House version: H.R. 1237 and Status). In Koricic v. Beverly Enters., 278 Neb. 713 (No. S-08-1167), Frank Koricic took his elderly mother, Manda Baker, to Beverly Hallmark (now operating as Beverly Enterprises), a
Legal Research
Recent Posts
Search
Legal Research
© 2025, Karl Bayer. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy