Menu
Fifth Circuit
Fifth Circuit Holds Motion to Compel Arbitration Not Enough to Defeat Preliminary Injunction
By Beth Graham - January 5, 2011
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals has held that a motion to compel arbitration did not defeat a federal district court’s preliminary injunction. In Janvey v. Alguire, et al., No. 10-10617, (5th Cir. December 15, 2010), the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission filed suit in U.S. district court against the Stanford Group and other related corporate entities (collectively Stanford) alleging that Stanford perpetrated a multi-billion-dollar Ponzi
2010 Arbitration Case Law: Fifth Circuit
By Beth Graham - December 31, 2010
In 2010, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit decided the following arbitration-related cases: In Hall-Williams v. Law Office of Paul C. Miniclier, PLC, No. 09-30113, (5th Cir., Jan. 13, 2010), the Fifth Circuit compelled arbitration of a fees dispute between a law firm and a former client. The court held the parties’ arbitration clause was enforceable notwithstanding termination of their services contract. (read more here) In
Fifth Circuit Holds Arbitration Provision Illusory and Unenforceable
By Beth Graham - October 29, 2010
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals has held in an unpublished opinion that an arbitration provision in a multilevel marketing program contract which could be amended at the sole discretion of one party and bound the other party “upon notice” was illusory and unenforceable. In Juan Torres v. S.G.E. Management, L.L.C., No. 09-20778, (5th Cir., October 5, 2010), Ignite operated as a subsidiary of a retail provider of electricity in Texas. Ignite rel
Fifth Circuit Denies Compelled Arbitration Under Theory of Direct Benefits Estoppel
By Beth Graham - September 27, 2010
The 5th Circuit Court of Appeals has held that a court may not compel arbitration under the theory of direct benefits estoppel where there was no evidence a party had actual knowledge a contract containing an arbitration clause existed and no attempt was made by the party to enforce the specific provision which contained the arbitration clause. In Noble Drilling Services, Inc. v. Certex USA, Inc., No. 10-20083 (5th Cir., September 15, 2010), Nobl
Fifth Circuit Rules Courts Lack Inherent Authority to Impose Sanctions for Arbitral Conduct
By Beth Graham - September 15, 2010
The Fifth Circuit has held that it lacks inherent authority to impose sanctions for conduct which occurred during arbitration. In Positive Software Solutions, Inc. v. New Century Mortgage Corp., No. 09-10355, (5th Cir., September 13, 2010), Positive Software Solutions sued New Century for allegedly infringing telemarketing software licensed to New Century. The case was subsequently ordered to arbitration under the terms of the parties’ contract.
Fifth Circuit Rules Arbitrability Question is for Arbitrator to Decide Where Parties Clearly Intended So
By Beth Graham - September 9, 2010
The Fifth Circuit has held that the question of arbitrability is for an arbitrator to decide where an arbitration agreement exists between the parties and they clearly intended for the issue to be arbitrated based on the wording of the arbitration provision. In Allen v. Regions Bank, No. 09-60705, (5th Cir., August 11, 2010), plaintiffs (the Allens) obtained a home equity loan from First American National Bank in October 1999. The bank withheld f
Law Review Article | Still Litigating Arbitration in the Fifth Circuit, But Less Often
By Victoria VanBuren - September 2, 2010
We invite you to read Donald R. Philbin, Jr. and Audrey Lynn Maness‘ latest Fifth Circuit law review article, Still Litigating Arbitration in the Fifth Circuit, But Less Often, 42 Tex. Tech L. Rev. 551 (2010). Here is an excerpt: Arbitration remains under national klieg lights. It has “become a wide-ranging surrogate for civil litigation” in a wider variety of contracts than at any time in our nation?s history. This increased use has reveal
Fifth Circuit Finds Arbitration Waiver
By Victoria VanBuren - August 17, 2010
The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit held that a defendant had waived its right to compel arbitration because its substantial invocation of the judicial process had prejudiced the plaintiff. In MC Asset Recovery, LLC v. Castex Energy, Inc., No. 09-10451 (5th Cir. Aug. 2, 2010) MC Asset Recovery, LLC (MCAR) sued Castex Energy, Inc. (Castex) alleging breach of a purchase and sale agreement. The district court denied Castex’
Fifth Circuit Rules that Unions and Employees May Contract to Exclude Certain Claims from Arbitration Under the RLA
By Victoria VanBuren - August 5, 2010
The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit held that a grievance concerning a pilot’s discharge is not subjected to the Railroad Labor Act’s (RLA) mandatory arbitration mechanism because the collective bargaining agreement (CBA) between the airline and its pilot’s union explicitly excluded the claim. In CareFlite v. AFL-CIO, No. 08-10807 (5th Cir. Jul. 13, 2010) CareFlite is a medical transportation company that em
Disputing Blog Cited by Law Review Article: ‘Still Litigating Arbitration in the Fifth Circuit, But Less Often’
By Victoria VanBuren - August 4, 2010
We are pleased to share with you that our blog Disputing has been cited by the law review article Still Litigating Arbitration in the Fifth Circuit, But Less Often, 42 Tex. Tech L. Rev. 551 (2010) by Donald R. Philbin, Jr. and Audrey Lynn Maness. Kudos to the authors! The article can be accessed via Westlaw or LexisNexis. These are the Disputing blog posts cited by the article: Hall Street Meets S. Maestri Place: What Standards of Review Will the
Legal Research
Recent Posts
Search
Legal Research
© 2025, Karl Bayer. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy